Activity – Where Am I Going Reflection Sheet

As regular Radical readers know, I’ve been tinkering with student-involved assessment practices over the past several years.  My goal is to turn feedback into detective work — a concept that assessment expert Dylan Wiliam argues is essential to producing the kinds of self-reliant, reflective learners that will succeed in an increasingly complex work world.

To push that kind of work forward in my room, I’m thinking about building on John Hattie’s assertion in Visible Learning (2009) that the best feedback helps students to answer three questions:  “Where am I going? (learning intentions/goals/success criteria), How am I going? (self assessment and self evaluation), and  Where to next? (progression/new goals)” (Kindle Location 3995).

So I’ve developed several versions of what I’m calling a “Where am I Going Reflection Sheet.”  Check them out here:

Where am I Going Reflection Sheet

My plan is to ask students to return to this reflection sheet several times over the course of a unit to think carefully about the ongoing expectations for classroom lessons and the evidence that they can collect to prove that they are mastering essential content and/or skills.  The goal is to help students realize that setting goals, monitoring progress, and identifying areas for continued improvement are natural steps taken by learners.

Some of the templates that I’ve developed are explicit, defining the essential outcomes, sources of evidence, and strategies for moving forward in advance. Others are less explicit, requiring students to demonstrate a greater grasp of the expectations and opportunities in each sequence of instruction.  My guess is that I’d use these templates to differentiate instruction in my classroom, handing out the explicit templates to students who struggle to set their own direction and monitor their own progress towards mastering essential content.

Does any of this make sense to all y’all?  More importantly, does this seem like a practice worth pursuing?  What changes would you make to the templates that I’ve created?


Related Radical Reads:

Peer Feedback Should Start with Observations, not Evaluations

Feedback Should Be More Work for the Recipient

Giving Feedback Should Be a Work For/Work On Process

4 thoughts on “Activity – Where Am I Going Reflection Sheet

  1. Kim

    This is a great way for teachers to learn from their students. It creates a collaborative environment as well as one where each student should be able explain what they are learning and the evidence they have gathered along the way and share with their teacher. Love the way you can differentiate at the high school level.

  2. alimcollins

    I seriously LOVE this idea! Thanks for sharing and please follow up with your reflections on how they work out. I’d also be interested in hearing how something like this might be adapted for middle school and upper elementary age students. This would definitely have to be simplified, but I still think the idea of having students set, monitor and reflect on their OWN learning goals is the key to them feeling empowered as learners.

    1. Bill Ferriter Post author

      It’s interesting, Ali — People tell me all the time that they think this kind of work is too hard for elementary students. My pushback is always the same: Maybe it’s hard because we never ask students to do it! I wonder if this kind of stuff would be approachable if we did it more often.

      Any thoughts?

  3. moreatforty speechteach

    I think this is a great idea. I teach college and I often feel, even at that level, students do not see the connections between reading, in-class activities, quizzes and exams. They view everything as an independent assignment. Something like this would help them to see and realize the way their knowledge and mastery will be measured. And it would force me to consider those same things. 🙂

Comments are closed.